Legal Research > Sentencing Tables

This table is intended to be used as a guide only. Individual cases should be read if they are to be relied upon.

 

Robbery - Aggravated - With Wounding: s.96 

s.96: Commits offence under s95 and wounds or inflicts GBH - 25y

Case Offence Plea Sentence Appeal Record Facts

Binge
(35)
NSW CCA
6.4.1995

s.96

VG

MT 6y
AT 4y

Conviction and sentence AD
(parity)

V confronted by three men in his house. Punched and hit with stick. Tied up. Lost consciousness.
Instigator and inflicted the wounds.

MRB
(17)
NSWCCA
27.4.1998

s.96

Sched:
Mal wounding
Assault

PG

MT 3y
AT 3y

AD

drug, property and personal offences in Children's Court

Removed V's wallet while being fellated by him in public toilet. Stabbed V three times in chest. Problems with controlling anger.

B
(17)
NSW CCA
18.90.1998

s.96

PG

MT 27m
AT 2y
(PSC 1m)

AA
MT 2y
AT 2y

nil

Arranged with co-accused to rob 64y former landlady. Entered house through ruse, secured V and obtained several hundred dollars. Placed cardigan over V's head and hit her with iron pipe. Principal actor.
Favourable references. Received one third discount for assistance.

George


Johnson

NSW CCA [243]
30.6.1999

s.96


s.96

VG


VG

MT 5y 6m
AT 3y 6m

MT 5y 9m
AT 3y 3m

AD

agg BES


several

Met V in bar and became friendly - Later in evening robbed and assaulted V - Used broken beer bottles to cut V - Severe injuries - Gratuitous brutal violence.

Pham
(25)
NSW CCA [225]
2.8.1999

s.96 (in company)

Sched:
3 x GIC
Receiving

PG

MT 3y
AT 2y 6m

AD

unknown

Robbed shop assistant with co-offender - Armed with knife while co-offender armed with loaded pistol - Struck V with handle of knife
Drug problem

Haines
(26)
NSW CCA [256]
4.7.2001

s.96

PG

4y
NPP 3y

AD

priors; previous custody.

Female - With co-offender robbed taxi driver of $50. Held knife to V's throat causing laceration. Co-offender wounded V in back. Aboriginal.

Teoka
(22)y

Lloyd
(18)y

ADM
(17)

NSW CCA [373]
1.11.2004

s.96



s.96



s.96

PG



PG



PG

10y
NPP 6y


10y 9m
NPP 6y 9m


11y
NPP 7y

AA
(to backdate sentence)

AA
10y
NPP 6y

AA
10y
NPP 6y

Convictions for assault - breached bail

Convictions for rob in company - breached bail

Conviction for robbery - no previous imprisonment

Punched and kicked male victim until unconscious - Serious injuries - ADM took wallet - T instigated assault - ADM instigated robbery
T - remorse - upset at time of offence over breakdown in relationship with de facto - good prospects of rehabilitation
L - remorse - disturbed childhood
ADM - No remorse - more culpable than others

Nasher
(18)
NSW CCA [238]
28.6.2005

s 96

PG

6y
NPP 3y
(52d PSC taken into account)

AA
4y
NPP 2y

Minor record as juvenile; offences in breach of bail

Attacked acquaintance from school - thought friends were going to rob V - fractured V's jaw and took $100 - jealous of V's comfortable financial situation
18% for PG - not all PSC taken into account - eldest of 8 children in dysfunctional family - NESB - sexually abused as a child - good employment record - good prospects of rehabilitation

Maisey
NSWCCA [347]
11.10.2005

s 96

PG

9y
NPP 5y 9m

AD

Not stated but breached parole

V physically abused A's sister - A went to V's flat with a friend to get some shoes he had given his sister - punched V when he opened the door - took V's wallet - V jumped off balcony and sustained serious injuries with chronic back pain
Remorse - family loyalty

Collins
(19)
NSWCCA [162]
22.5.2006

s.96

VG

8y
NPP 5y

AA sentence backdated only. Term of sentence remains 8y NPP 5y.

On bond. Dishonesty, assault, AOABH, larceny.

Female - Slashed V's handbag strap with knife taking $500 - In tandem with V's estranged husband - Knew V was vulnerable with spinal injury and using crutch.
Background of heroin and prostitution; paranoid personality disorder.

MW

(17)

NSW CCA [324]

17.12.2010

s.96

PG

3y 3mNPP 1y 9m

AA

2y 9m

NPP 1y 6m

limited

Part of groups who assaulted and robbed male at train station in early hours of morning – not instigator of offence. Long delay between arrest and sentence - aboriginal

JT

(17)

NSW CCA [128]

10.6.2011

s.96

PG

6yNPP 3y 2m

AD

Assault, assault police, resist police. AOABH, larceny. On good behaviour bonds

Aged 16 at time of offence - In company of co-offender, assaulted victim (aged 14) asking for money – kicked and stomped V on head – V rendered unconscious –violence sustained and substantial. Substance abuse – troubled youth - longstanding anger problems

SJ

(17)

NSW CCA [160]

14.7.2011

s.96

PG

5y 11m 12dNPP 3y 2m

AD

Nil

Leader of five youths who attacked 14y male on street at night – victim punched and stomped on head – shoes, wallet and wristwatch stolen – premeditated attack – leader seeking to maintain his reputation – no remorse

Lobsey

NSWCCA [239]

21.11.2012

s.96

PG

7y 6mNPP 5y

AD

Lengthy including violence

Grabbed bag from 73 female in car park causing her to fall heavily – continued to pull bag dragging victim across ground – victim broke neck and femur and had hip replacement. Genuine contrition – drug and alcohol user