This table is intended to be used as a guide only. Individual cases should be read if they are to be relied upon.
Maximum penalty: 20 years imprisonment
Standard non-parole period: 10 years imprisonment (offences committed on or after 1.2.2003)
2 x s.61J
2 x s.61E(1A)
(other sentences concurrent)
MT 3y 6m
Sexual assault on 14y female by three men – Victim visiting offenders - Offender forced intercourse while co-offender holding victim down – forced fellatio – subjected to vaginal and oral intercourse simultaneously by co-offenders then anal intercourse by offender while co-offenders continued vaginal intercourse – principal offender
Assistance against co-offenders – fear for safety – assisted in care for crippled father
AT 2y 8m
MT 5y 3m
AT 1y 9m
Penile / vaginal. Met complainant at nightclub. Drove her home, stopping three times to make aggressive passes. At home intercourse against will, slapped face when she protested. Swelling and bruising to jaw throat and hand.
Minor basketball player from USA
MT 5y 6m
Cleaner in complainant's workplace attacked her when working back
Powerful subjective case
MT 2y 6m
(concurrent sentence for indecent ass)
4 similar off
MT 7y 6m
AT 2y 6m
5 x s.61J
4 x indecent ass
(concurrent sentences for indecent ass)
on recog for sex
MT 2y 3m
6 x s.61J
4 x s.61J
MT 4y 6m
AT 1y 6m
10 x s.61J
3 x s.61L
3 x s.61J
Forced 11y girl walking past into house – Struck on side of head – Penile intercourse and 2 x oral intercourse – threatened with further assault
committed second count while on bail for first count
2 x s. 61J
Minor – Breached PD and recog
Together sexually assaulted 17y C after party. C tied up. Both fondled breasts, digitally penetrated C and made her fellate them
B – dominant role - borderline mentally deficient.
Raped C twice after following her as she was walking home.
Suffered brain damage in car accident and became sexually aggressive and dangerous when drunk.
extensive although no sex
Forced entry into home of young female living alone. Assaulted and threatened her. Made multiple attempts to penetrate anally and vaginally, finally succeeding in the former. In response to resistance choked C so hard she could not breathe.
2 x 61M(1)
MT 2y 9m
AT 1y 3m
MT 3y 9m
2 x BES
(concurrent sentence for BES)
(threaten inflict abh)
prior assault on wife
wife had applied for AVO
(threaten to inflict abh)
1 x s.80A(2)
Picked up C and friend hitch-hiking and drove them to secluded beach. Assaulted C by placing string around throat and arm around neck. Further bruises to both girls.
Twelve months later picked up C2 hitch-hiking. Threatened C with knife and handcuffed her. Fellatio, digital, forced C to insert own finger, various sexual and physical threats. Drove and performed more sexual assaults on beach. Total time was seven hours.
Two days later performed similar assaults on another woman in Queensland.
AT 3y 6m
16y C walking alone along canal 2pm. Dragged into bushes and demanded money. Assaulted, stripped, and jumper tied around eyes. Multiple sexual acts, including fellatio.
Pleaded guilty on second day of second trial.
5 x s.61M(1)
(2y concurrent sentence for indecent ass)
Entered flat of 19y female – threatened with knife – 5 x vaginal intercourse, 1 x digital penetration of anus and 2 x oral intercourse
Aboriginal with deprived background
2 x s.61O(2)
(use of knife / punching C)
MT 1y 4m
offence occurred in gaol
Possess unauth firearm
 NSWCCA 104
Sched: Take and drive conveyance
Stole car with co-offender and 13y C – car driven until broke down in remote place – C dragged into bush land, ordered to remove clothes and threatened with piece of wood - co-offender had penile intercourse - A had anal intercourse - Tore clothes and left C tied to tree.
[Co-offender aged 16 years]. Pleaded guilty at earliest opportunity. Assisted authorities against co-offender. Imprisonment to be served in protective custody.
 NSWCCA 239
FT 2y 6m
MT 8y 9m
AT 2y 3m
MT 6y 6m
(2y concur sentence for indecent ass)
No factual details - Breach of familial trust
 NSWCCA 338
(mal inflict abh)
Records for assaults although not serious.
Offence reached AVO.
Aboriginal male sexually assaulted wife. Penile intercourse, inserted metal bottle into vagina, then inserted boondi stick into vagina and anus.
 NSWCCA 14
B M T
 NSWCCA 112
Sched: Mal damage
Subsequent acquittal of matter on record does not effect sentence
 NSWCCA 117
Attacked 13y walking along footpath - Punched her, demanded money then attempted to have sexual intercourse.
Chronically dysfunctional - Dangerous - Drug addiction
 NSWCCA 147
Total: MT 8y
 NSWCCA 265
(concurrent sentences for assaults)
 NSWSC 716
(2002) 132 A Crim R 72
 NSWCCA 286
(threat to inflict abh)
2 x s.61K
Assaults committed on 8 complainants over 12 month period late at night. C threatened with knife and subjected to digital or penile penetration. Offences premeditated and planned. Observed by police stalking other women. No significant physical injuries inflicted.
Significant risk of re-offending.
 NSWCCA 343
NPP 2y 3m
Forced 11y cousin to engage in intercourse causing pregnancy. Took advantage of family context.
Remorse - suffering schizo-effective disorder.
 NSWCCA 448
Assaulted 13y male relation while asleep – Sharing bedroom -forced anal intercourse.
Sexually abused as a teenager. Retrial. Protection.
 NSWCCA 446
 NSWCCA 468
J C E
(2000) 120 A Crim R 18
 NSWCCA 498
Sexually assaulted daughter on two occasions. Inserted finger in vagina, and licked vaginal area.
Suspended from Pre-trial Diversion Scheme for unsatisfactory progress and breaches of undertaking. Had made some efforts at program and was remorseful.
 NSWCCA 49
AT 3y 3m
 NSWCCA 96
 NSWCCA 186
Forced ex-wife to have oral and vaginal sex using knife.
Evidence of good character.
 NSWCCA 471
NPP 5y 6m
Sexually assaulted C while out riding on motorbike - Injuries to back, thighs, genital and anal area.
Protective custody - Unhappy childhood - Sexually assaulted over 2 years
 NSWCCA 341
(under 16y and under authority)
Sexually assaulted 10y step-daughter and friend
Severe back pain proving unmanageable in custody - sentence reduced to take into account fact that medical condition worse than appreciated at time sentence imposed.
 NSWCCA 354
Forced 14y schoolgirl into toilets at public park using knife - indecently assaulted her and forced penis into mouth for short time.
Unstable family life - Rehabilitation.
 NSWCCA 475
NPP 5y 9m
(4y concurrent sentence for s.61I)
Forced female acquaintance to have oral and anal intercourse - Punched her in face – C of limited intellect.
Married with 3 young children - alcoholic at early age - some evidence of rehabilitation
(2001) 127 A Crim R 493
 NSWCCA 504
(serious disability and under care)
NPP 5y 3m
 NSWCCA 58
NPP 3y 6m
traffic, property and dishonesty offences - no violence - 2 recog
no similar offences - illegal use of motor vehicle
Two 16y females offered lift by respondents late at night - taken to house, separated and subjected to four hours of degrading sexual assaults - physical violence, threatened with knife and death threats
AEM - adversely affected by father's death - Substance abuse
KEM - affected by father's death - difficult schooling
MM - cousin to co-offenders - difficult childhood after father left
 NSWCCA 119
2 x s.61J (person in authority)
12 related off
NPP 3y 4m 13d
(3y concurrent sentence for indecent assault)
Sexually abused teenage daughter over 4 year period
Remorse and contrition - Protective custody – Breakdown of marriage – Willingness to seek counselling – Suicide risk
 NSWCCA 107
2 x Agg indecent ass
(under 16 and under authority)
NPP 2y 9m
Came into stepdaughter's bedroom at night on two occasions and rubbed her arm along penis - Received treatment for behaviour and returned to family unit - Sucked penis of stepson several years later.
Receiving treatment – Prospects of rehabilitation reasonable – Protective custody
(2002) 129 A Crim R 242
[2002 NSWCCA 159
 NSWCCA 258
2 x att s.61J
(concurrent sentences imposed for indecent ass)
 NSWCCA 311
2 x breach bond [agg indecent assault]
NPP 4y 9m
(concurrent sentences for bonds)
(2002) 132 A Crim R 308
 NSWCCA 320
NPP 8y 6m
Took 6y step daughter and tied her to bed head - Gagged - Forced penile/vaginal intercourse while C screaming - Caused major injury to vagina
Fijian - Protection - Remorse
 NSWCCA 346
Digital penetration in 13y stepdaughter.
No further details.
 NSWCCA 487
NPP 2y 6m
Stepfather of 14y complainant - Anal intercourse on two occasions and fellatio.
Stable and supportive family. Suffering from spina bifida. Need for medical treatment in custody. Protective custody. Prior good character and reputation as caring father.
Sentence manifestly inadequate.
(2002) 137 A Crim R 326
(2002) NSWCCA 516
s.61I x 2
(5y concurrent sentences for s.61I)
Lured 16y old female to isolated area - Handcuffed wrists - Threatened with knife - Fellatio and penile-vaginal intercourse.
 NSWCCA 137
NPP 7y 6m
Broke into home of 15y C and waited in bedroom – Threatened C with knife and forced vaginal intercourse – C a virgin
Aboriginal with early drug and alcohol abuse
 NSWCCA 341
(sentence inadequate but appeal dismissed in exercise of discretion)
Attacked estranged wife in bedroom and forced cucumber into vagina twice – Vicious and violent attack
 NSWCCA 48
s.61J x 4
s.61L Indecent assault
 NSWCCA 125
NPP 4y 6m
Violent assault on wife in matrimonial home culminating in forced intercourse
Error in find offence aggravated because took place at home
 NSWCCA 128
(victim under 16y)
11-12y female assaulted by father of friend – Stayed at appellant's house – Appellant placed fingers in or around vagina on two occasions while complainant in bed – breach of trust
Good character – protective custody – volunteer firefighter
 NSWCCA 105
Prolonged and bizarre assault on girlfriend included forcing cigar deep into vagina and taking sexually explicit photos
Suffering manic episode stage of bipolar disorder – Unprecedented behaviour – Unlikely to re-offend if take medication
 NSWCCA 251
In company with co-offender had intercourse with 15y intoxicated complainant at Darling Harbour
Low intelligence – difficult background in El Salvador
 NSWCCA 295
Sexually assaulted female friend at night in street – Assault caused unconsciousness – threatened nearby resident
Long history of drug and alcohol abuse – suffering schizophrenia and frontal lobe damage – not given medication on release from custody – combination of mental illness and alcohol and drug injection reduced culpability
 NSWCCA 468
(CCA - 25%)
NPP 13y 6m
Penile-vaginal penetration with intellectually disabled 13-14y female (mental age of 8-9y), who became pregnant as a result – pregnancy terminated – Previous relationship with V's mother – Admitted further acts of intercourse with V
Institutionalised as a child – "uncontrollable" child – suicide attempt – very poor health, heart problems
 NSWCCA 208
NPP 1y 9m
SNPP 10 years
In relationship with 15y V – In presence of 22y cousin fondled V and inserted finger in her vagina against her wishes – Cousin exposed himself and offered $100 for sex
Agreed to give evidence against cousin - High risk of re-offending – low opinion of non-Muslim women – low IQ – poor impulse control
 NSWCCA 308
Agg ind ass
Sexually assaulted 16y daughter with mental problems – Only just re-entered daughter's life – Penile-digital penetration
Mental condition and long term alcohol addiction
 NSWCCA 293
Babysitting 11y step-niece by marriage – digitally penetrated vagina for about 15min – conviction appeal only
(67 at sentence)
 NSWCCA 135
Sexually assaulted female acquaintance in her home – inflicted actual bodily harm
Ill health – very elderly mother – delay caused by failure to appear
 NSWCCA 10
2 x s.61I
Sexually assaulted estranged wife – punched and hit her to head – forced penile / vaginal and anal intercourse – chased complainant from house – threats to kill - attempted suicide – impulsive offence – intoxicated and depressed – below mid range
(2007) 167 A Crim R 424
[2007 NSWCCA 21
Sexually assaulted female stranger on secluded beach – threatened with knife.
 NSWCCA 59
Sexual assaults upon 16y niece – offences part of wider conduct.
Sentences made cumulative.
 NSWCCA 222
Facts not stated.
Special circumstances. Ill-health, age, depression.
 NSWCCA 274
(imposed for s.61JA)
Conviction AA: s.61JA replaced by s.61J
Priors and breached conditional liberty – not regarded as serious in circumstances of case
T forced female friend to perform fellatio at request of co-offender E – acting under an element of duress from aggressive and violent conduct of E – P forced fellatio and vaginal intercourse under similar duress – offences well below mid-range – both offenders could have done more to prevent offences
T – remorse – protective custody – psychological problems
P – prior good character
(2008) 184 A Crim R 534
 NSWCCA 106
13y friend of A' daughter invited to sleepover party – A gave V alcohol – offered to massage V – touched V on groin area and performed cunnilingus – V in shock and protested - Spontaneous offence – assessed as below middle range of objective seriousness - breach of trust
Good character – upstanding member of community.
 NSWCCA 195
NPP 6y 6m
Accompanied 26y female to unit – Bashed V over head and body with piece of wood – Forced sexual intercourse – Detained for some time during which subjected V to further taunts and assaults - Close to worst category of offence.
(2008) 189 A Crim R 332
 NSWCCA 244
 NSWCCA 14
Sexual assault on 10y girl in unit – anal penetration with finger, penis and vibrator – penetration of genitalia
Mental illness - segregation
 NSWCCA 42
Commenced consensual intercourse with acquaintance in boarding house room – forced attempted anal intercourse – threatened to cut throat – head butted and punched Victim's face – Forced penis into mouth – detained V in room for some time
Under influence of alcohol, cannabis and prescription drugs
(2009) 193 A Crim R 292
 NSWCCA 48
Grabbed 16y old female victim walking at night – dragged V behind bushes – punched V on face and made threatening remarks – penile vaginal intercourse.
Dysfunctional background. SJ erred in categorising case as worst category case. Sentence manifestly excessive.
 NSWCCA 154
Assaulted 81y female Korean tourist walking in park in early morning – threw to ground and punched – digital and penile penetration – no explanation for offence – intoxication – spontaneous offence – vulnerable victim under s.21A(2)(l)
Good character – good prospects of rehabilitation – genuine remorse
 NSWCCA 184
2 x s.61O Agg act indecency
AA in part otherwise AD.
Not interfered with.
Assaulted 11y daughter over 6 month period –part penile vaginal penetration – digital penetration.
Voluntary disclosure to police – remorse – psychotic disorder.
Mid-range objective seriousness.
Failure by SJ to comply with s45 Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 in respect of Count 1 – Court must set non-parole period for that count.
 NSWCCA 156
s. 61J (inflict ABH)
1 x offence
Followed 24 year old victim on street at night – grabbed victim and tried to kiss her – punched victim twice to face – undid victim's trousers – inserted finger in vagina and anus – committed offence on way home from work at restaurant – intoxicated.
Less than mid-range.
Hardship to third party – wife pregnant.
 NSWCCA 289
s. 61J (V under 16)
2 x agg indecent assault; Act of indecency
(CCA – 25%)
Offences occurred 13 years ago in 1997 – Applicant then aged 22 - Oral intercourse with 14 year old male victim – friend of family – not isolated incident – abuse took place over 6 months.
No evidence that A had abused or would abuse again – A lonely at time due to lack of warmth in his own family – good character.
SJ erred in not giving discount for guilty plea.
 NSWCCA 243
Sexually assaulted 12 year old girl who was sleeping at the home of a friend and at which A was also staying – penile / vaginal intercourse and digital penetration.
Borderline personality disorder – mental health issues – cannabis dependence – these matters reduced objective seriousness of offence.
 NSWCCA 203
s.61J (inflict ABH)
Possess restricted substance
NPP 7y 9m
NPP 6y 3m
Sexually assaulted partner on two separate occasions two months apart – forced penile / vaginal intercourse on first occasion – forced oral / vaginal intercourse and attempted penile / vaginal intercourse on second occasion
Abusive childhood – good work record – appeal allowed to increase concurrence of sentences
 NSWCCA 217
Headmaster of school sexually assaulted 14y student staying with his family for two weeks – victim fell asleep after taking tablets from offender – awoke to find offender forcing penile / vaginal intercourse – just below mid-range – vulnerable victim
[prior good character – hardship in custody – loss of teaching career
 NSWCCA 13
Stepfather sexually assaulted 9-10y daughter on at least two occasions – entered bedroom of victim early in morning – cunnilingus and placed penis in victim's hand – prior good character
 NSWCCA 60
Attempt agg sexual assault
Sexually assaulted 15y old daughter of ex-partner who was home alone with her two younger siblings – vaginal-penile intercourse.
A knew no adult was home and that V was vulnerable - previous familial relationship of stepfather and stepdaughter also placed V in a vulnerable position - conduct amounted to a breach of trust.
Drug abuse – depression – supportive partner and children.
 NSWCCA 133
7 x s.61J
3 x s.35
Offences committed on 19y de facto over eight months – assaulted victim with iron bar – forced mousse bottle into vagina – stabbed victim with fork and chisel and forced intercourse – assaulted victim with baseball bat and forced vaginal and anal intercourse – punched victim causing broken jaw – assaulted victim with iron bar and forced oral intercourse, fellatio and vaginal intercourse – deliberately cut leg of victim with broken plate – assaulted victim with hammer, bat and golf club forcing intercourse with electrical cord around neck
(39 at sentence)
 NSWCCA 143
2 x s.61J(1)
4 x s.61M(1)
NPP 3y 3m
Van der Baan
 NSWCCA 5
NPP 14y 3m
NPP 12y 9m
1995-6 – Arranged to meet 18y female acquaintance – walked victim to park area and threatened victim with knife – forced penile/vaginal intercourse, anal intercourse and fellatio – tied up victim and stole property – 16m later grabbed 15y female walking along bridge in early evening – threatened with knife – forced fellatio, digital penetration and vaginal intercourse – each attack callous and degrading and caused significant psychological and physical injury
Totality to sentence imposed for similar offences
 NSWCCA 228
s.38- administer intoxicating drug with intent
2 x s.61J(1) (victim aged under 16y)
(sentence for s.61J offences:
Befriended 14y female stranger at wharf and commenced drinking – supplied Xanax tablet lying about effect – victim accompanied offender home before passing out – placed naked in offender's bed and sexually assaulted – cunnilingus and penile / vaginal intercourse
 NSWCCA 240
NPP 2y 8m
NPP 4y 10m
Sexually assaulted 11y niece – woke victim in her bed and forced vaginal intercourse, ejaculating into vagina – drunk at time of offence – refused to stop when asked by victim – victim had to be tested for sexually transmitted diseases
Drug and alcohol addiction commenced after suicide of father
 NSWCCA 14
2 x s. 61I
2 x s 61I
Sexually assaulted fellow male inmate whilst in remand – offences occurred in 2004 when aged 24 and victim aged 19.
Aboriginal – disturbed upbringing – virtually no education – psychiatric illness – drug abuse
 NSWCCA 60
2 x 61J
Sexually assaulted V who was highly intoxicated – did not know V - met V and friends at railway station at night and accompanied them to a club – assured V's friends he would take V home in a taxi but instead took V to his home – digital, vaginal and anal penetration.
Prior good character.
 NSWCCA 148
s 61J – FT 2y suspended
s 61L - GBB s 9
Crown AA s61J:
Crown AD s 61L
Sexually assaulted ex-girlfriend – could not accept V wanted to end relationship – would not allow V to leave A's apartment – forced vaginal intercourse – threatened V.
Below mid-range - sentencing judge erred in finding offence "at bottom of range."
 NSWCCA 162
1994 and 1996 offences
Offences committed 1994 and 1996 on victim aged 13 / 15y by mother's boyfriend – on first occasion but under influence of acid – exposed penis and rubbed vagina – digital penetration – mid range
 NSWCCA 267
Offence took place in 2005 - Sexually assaulted female V overseas tourist – had offered V a lift – stopped and threatened V with knife – oral and penile intercourse.
Offence of serious gravity.
Mental health issues.
 NSWCCA 303
9 x s.61JH
2 x s.61M(1)
(to set NPP – same effective total sentence)
Sexually abused stepdaughter aged 13-16y over 3 years – forced penile / vaginal intercourse while sharing beds in hotels and taking rest breaks in motor vehicles – on occasions provided sleeping tablets – anal intercourse and fellatio – touched vagina – similar sexual misconduct on other occasions both at home and away travelling – offences towards mid-range
Aggravating factors - Complainant under 16 years and under authority
Prior good character – mental health problems
 NSWCCA 5
 HCA 9
 NSWCCA 166
12m custody while waiting HCA
(exercise of discretion)
Sexually abused daughter aged 11-12 over 2005-2006 – touched on vagina – kissed and licked vagina on multiple occasions
Entered pre-trial diversion program for other offences – confessed to additional offences in assessment period – judge erroneously imposed non-custodial sentence in light of pre-trial program
High Court found error in approach to exercise of discretion on Crown appeal
2015 - Evidence of rehabilitation – serious medical conditions
 NSWCCA 53
2 x s.37
NPP 10y 6m
Straddled girlfriend in bed and attempted to choke when she refused sexual intercourse – later choked until V blacked out when she asked him to leave – V woke up bound and gagged on bed – cut dress of V with scissors – took V to bathroom to vomit then forced shower – returned to bed and forc4ed penile / vaginal intercourse
Sustained serious brain injury from prison assault after trial
 NSWCCA 140
2 x s.61M
Lesser FT concurrent
Sexually assaulted 12y friend of daughter staying at offender's house – invited V to watch movie on sofa bed in lounge – touched breasts and genitals – cunnilingus – penile penetration – one incident
 NSWCCA 192
Targeted attack of 15 year old female at night as V walking home – grabbed V and held knife to neck – penile-vaginal, digital intercourse and cunnilingus.
 NSWCCA 282
Sexual intercourse with SE female - circumstances of aggravation V aged 14 years and under A's authority as SE's teacher and headmaster of school V was attending – with consent of V's family, was taking care of V - A drugged V and waited until V was sleeping before having intercourse - criminal culpability considerable - significant degree of deliberation and premeditation.
 NSWCCA 6
Placed hands over windpipe of prostitute while she was performing oral sex – caused victim to become unconscious and forced penile / vaginal intercourse – victim awoke still being choked – took handbag and made threat to kill – used condom
Longstanding psychiatric problems
 NSWCCA 83
2 x Att s.61J
Offences took place in 1991 – cold case DNA – A arrested in 2011 – V female aged 57 – babysitting at childrens' home - A entered home through window – digital anal and vaginal penetration – attempted penile penetration – hit V in face – left after 15 minutes – opportunistic offence, no significant planning.
Violent upbringing – employed.
 NSWCCA 89
15 year old female victim – V highly intoxicated whilst camping with A and her friends – A offered to take her home but took V to his residence – digital vaginal penetration – penile vaginal penetration – took V home.
Prior good character – suffering depressive illness.
 NSWCCA 111
 NSWCCA 172
(actual bodily harm)
Assaulted 55y female stranger walking along beach – punched victim in face and dragged her into bushes – digital penetration – licked and sucked genitals – choked to unconsciousness – threatened children – spontaneous offence
Voluntarily attended police station concerned may have committed offence while intoxicated – suffering depression and alcohol abuse – genuine contrition good prospects of rehabilitation
On appeal failed to give Ellis discount
 NSWCCA 300
Took 13y victim to hotel room and supplied alcohol – anal intercourse without consent in presence of male friend
 NSWCCA 102
V was applicant's eldest daughter – V aged between 11 and 13 – digital vaginal penetration – touching vagina.
Ellis discount – disclosure by applicant of aspects of offending not complained of by victim – remorse undermined by victim-blaming.
 NSWCCA 139
2 x Agg indecent assault
Agg incite act of indecency
Sexually abused 12-17y step daughter over 5 years – continued offending after matter originally reported to police but not pursued – caused pregnancy requiring abortion –rubbing of penis - fellatio – cunnilingus – digital and penile penetration of vagina – penile penetration of anus – criminality of high order
(31 at offence)
 NSWCCA 223
1993 offence – offered lift home to female met at bar – drove to bushland – pursued victim as she tried to run away – sustained assaulted – digital penetration – penile penetration – upper range of seriousness
Sentence accumulated to existing sentence - delay
Worked in nursing home - two victims with disability – digital penetration of anus of 82 year old female V while she was asleep – penile penetration of anus of second V.
In lowest 1% of population - mild intellectual disability.
 NSWCCA 252
s.61O(2A) (aggravated Act of indecency with filming)
Took 15y complainant to offender's home at night – complainant employee at offender's father's shop – forced fellatio – took photos of complainant's breasts – approaching mid-range
 NSWCCA 289
 NSWCCA 311
Detain for advantage
Manager of fast food restaurant took home 15y female employee – en route parked car and forced penile / vaginal intercourse – one month later offence repeated – first offence just below mid-range – second offence mid-range
Born in Afghanistan – childhood trauma – some evidence of efforts at rehabilitation in custody